3. Submitting an Article

To make a submission, select the Click Here link (under Start a New Submission) to proceed to the first step of the submission process.

Figure 5.4. Starting a Submission

Starting a Submission

3.1. Submission Step One: Starting the Submission

Step 1 ensures that the Author understands the journal's submission rules. The Author will have to pick the appropriate section to submit to, and will be provided with information on the journal's privacy statement, copyright notice, competing interest statement and/or author fees, if applicable. If you need any help the journal's technical support contact is provided at the top of this page.

Figure 5.5. Submission Steps Technical Support

Submission Steps Technical Support

First, if the journal charges submission fees, these will be presented to the author. If the journal does not charge submission fees, this section will not appear.

Figure 5.6. Author Fees

Author Fees

Next, the author must check each of the items from the submission checklist. These items were established in Journal Setup Step 3.1.

Figure 5.7. Submission Checklist

Submission Checklist

The journal's copyright policy will appear next, and, if configured as a requirement, the author will need to agree to this policy. If the journal has not added a Copyright Notice, this section will not appear.

Figure 5.8. Copyright Notice

Copyright Notice

Authors can then review the Privacy Statement. If the journal has not added a Privacy Statement, this section will not appear.

Figure 5.9. Journal's Privacy Statement

Journal's Privacy Statement

Finally, the author can add any comments, which will be visible to the editor. Move to the next step by hitting the Save and Continue button.

Figure 5.10. Comments for the Editor

Comments for the Editor

3.2. Submission Step Two: Uploading the Submission

Submission Step Two allows you to upload the submission file, typically a word-processing document.

  • Click Browse to open a Choose File window for locating the file on the hard drive of your computer.

  • Locate the file you wish to submit and highlight it.

  • Click Open on the Choose File window, which places the name of the file on this page.

  • Click Upload on this page, which uploads the file from the computer to the journal's web site and renames it following the journal's conventions.

  • Once the submission is uploaded, click Save and continue.

    Figure 5.11. Uploading the Submission

    Uploading the Submission

3.3. Submission Step Three: Entering the Submission's Metadata

The third step of the submission process serves to collect all relevant metadata from the author. The first section of metadata covers the authors. The submitting author will have their personal information automatically appear. Any additional information, such as Competing Interests should also be added at this time, if required.

Figure 5.12. Authors


If there are multiple authors for the submission, their information can be added using the Add Author button. You can also re-order the list of authors, make one of the authors the principal contact with the editor, and delete any authors added in error.

Figure 5.13. Biographical Statement

Biographical Statement

Next, enter the submission title and abstract.

Figure 5.14. Title and Abstract

Title and Abstract

You will then add indexing information. This will help others find your article. The suggested indexing options were determined by the Journal Manager in Setup Step 3.4.

Figure 5.15. Indexing


The final section allows you to enter the name of any organization that may have supported your research.

Figure 5.16. Supporting Agencies

Supporting Agencies

Hit the Save and Continue button to move on to Step 4.

3.4. Submission Step Four: Uploading Supplementary Files

This step is optional. If you have any supplementary files, such as research instruments, data sets, etc., you may add them here. These files are also indexed by the author, identifying their relation to the submission, as well as their ownership. Supplementary Files can be uploaded in any file format and will be made available to readers in their original format.

  • Locate the file you wish to submit and highlight it.

  • Click Open on the Choose File window, which places the name of the file on this page.

  • Click Upload on this page, which uploads the file from the computer to the journal's web site and renames it following the journal's conventions.

  • Once the submission is uploaded, click Save and Continue.

    Figure 5.17. Uploading Supplementary Files

    Uploading Supplementary Files

3.5. Submission Step Five: Confirming the Submission

This final step provides a summary of your submission.

Figure 5.18. Confirming the Submission

Confirming the Submission

If the journal charges submission, fast-track review, or publication fees, your required payment will also be detailed here. If you paid previously, use the checkbox to indicate that you have. If you require a fee waiver to be considered, check that box and an provide an explanation (required).

Figure 5.19. Author Fees

Author Fees

Click Finish Submission to submit your manuscript. You will receive an acknowledgement by email and will be able to view your submission's progress through the review and editorial process by returning to the Active Submissions section of your Author page.

3.6. Authors and Submission Review and Editing Process

To track your submission's progress through the review and editorial process, you will need to log into the journal web site, and choose your role as Author. Click on the linked title to go to the submission record.

Figure 5.20. Active Submissions

Active Submissions

3.6.1. Summary

From the resulting 'Summary' page, you will see links to Summary, Review, and Editing pages. Each of these pages will provide details about your submission.

Figure 5.21. Selecting Submission Summary

Selecting Submission Summary

The Summary section contains several sections, including Submission, which displays the author names, submission title, original submission file, any supplementary files, the ability to add a supplementary file, the name of the submitter, the date submitted, the section the article is assigned to, the editor responsible for the submission, and the comments to editor you made as part of your submission (see above).

Figure 5.22. Submission Summary

Submission Summary

The next section outlines any required author fees. If the journal does not charge author fees, this section will not appear.

Figure 5.23. Author Fees

Author Fees

The Status section lets you know where your submission is in the publishing process (see above for status possibilities). It also lets you know when you made your submission and the date of the most recent status change.

Figure 5.24. Status


The final section outlines the submission metadata, including author details, title, abstract, indexing, and supporting agency. You can modify any of this information by selecting Edit Metadata.

Figure 5.25. Submission Metadata

Submission Metadata

3.6.2. Review

If your submission is In Review, you can view its details in the Review section (linked from the top of your page).

Figure 5.26. Selecting Submission Review

Selecting Submission Review

First, you will see the basic submission information again.

Figure 5.27. Submission Information

Submission Information

Below that is the Peer Review section. You will see information about each round of review (there may be one or more) and any revised files (e.g., a version of your original submission file with changes marked in) uploaded by each reviewer (Reviewer A, Reviewer B, etc.).

Figure 5.28. Peer Review

Peer Review

Last on this page is the Editor Decision section. From this section you can notify the editor once you have submitted your revised submission file, view the reviewer comments (click on the cloud icon), and upload your revised submission file (if revisions were required).

Figure 5.29. Editor Decision

Editor Decision

Possible decisions include:

  • Accept: Your submission has been accepted as is.

  • Revisions Required: Your submission requires minor changes and will be accepted once those have been completed.

  • Resubmit for Review: Your submission needs significant re-working. A new file must be submitted and another round of review will take place.

  • Reject: Your submission was not accepted for publication with this journal, either because it was not seen to be of high enough quality, or its subject did not match the journal.

3.6.3. Editing

Your submission is considered "In Editing" once it has been approved for publication. It will then need to go through copyediting to correct any grammatical or stylistic errors, layout editing to create the published galleys (e.g., HTML or PDF), and proofreading to take one final look at the article before it is made publicly available.

If your submission is In Editing, you can view its details in the Editing section (linked from the top of your page). The first section again includes basic submission information.

Figure 5.30. Selecting Submission Editing

Selecting Submission Editing


In the next section, you can follow the copyediting process.

Figure 5.31. Copyediting


  • Step 1: The journal's Copyeditor has made changes to the reviewed submission file. You can download a revised copy here (e.g., 6-11-1-ED.DOCX).

  • Step 2: You will review the Copyeditor'ss changes, and make any final changes of your own. You then upload your revised submission file here. Be sure to use the email icon to notify the Copyeditor that you have submitted your file.

  • Step 3: The Copyeditor takes a last look at your changes before passing the submission over to the Layout Editor. No action is required by the author.


Copyedit comments can be added using the icon near the bottom of this section. There is also a link to "Copyedit Instructions".

Layout Editing

The next stage in the editorial process is layout editing. The Layout Editor takes the final copyedited version of the submission and converts it into a format suitable for publishing on the journal web site (e.g., typically HTML or PDF). These are known as the "galleys".

Figure 5.32. Layout



The final editing stage is proofreading. It is also broken down into 3 steps.

Figure 5.33. Proofreading


  1. Once the galleys have been uploaded by the Layout Editor, you will receive an email from the editor asking that you review them and note any errors in the Proofreading Corrections comments. Proofing Instructions are also available. To view these, you will need to login to the journal and select the appropriate submission link:

    Figure 5.34. Active Submissions

    Active Submissions

    On the resulting screen, you can use the View Proof links to display the files. You can click the linked file names (e.g, 1-95-1-PB.HTML) to download a copy.

    Figure 5.35. Layout


    Review the files and make any comments using the Layout Comments icon.

    Figure 5.36. Corrections


    Once you have completed your review and noted any necessary changes, hit the Complete button.

    Figure 5.37. Proofreading


    This will generate an email informing the Proofreader and Section Editor that you are satisfied with the galleys.

    Figure 5.38. Sending Email

    Sending Email

  2. The journal's own Proofreader will also check for errors and make their own notes and inform the Layout Editor when all proofreading is complete. No action is required by the Author.

  3. The Layout Editor takes all of the notes and incorporates all of the changes into revised galleys. These are then ready to publish. No action is required by the Author.

You have now completed all of the steps involved in submitting to the journal and participating in the review and editing of your submission.