Talk:Lemon8-XML Roadmap

From PKP Wiki
Revision as of 11:42, 3 February 2010 by Jerico.dev (Talk | contribs)

(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to: navigation, search

GUI specification Citation support in submission/editorial process

Citation Extraction/Insertion

  1. must-have: copy & paste
    We can use the existing text field in the submission process for "bulk citation insert":
    • enter citations (text-only) -> disable TinyMCE-plugin for citation field
    • "parse" button will split up citations (one per line?) and send them to the configured parser services
    • new: parsing should be non-blocking if possible - alternatively: a progress bar should appear
    • citation editor appears as soon as citations have been recognized
  2. optional: automatic extraction
    Use document parser to extract citations:
    • recognize .odt file type and try to extract citations
    • show citations in citation editor if citations have been found

Citation Parsing/Editing/Lookup

The current citation editor GUI is already very good. It has the following functionality:

  • open/close citation details (current bug: opening details for one citation should close all other citations)
  • save citation details
  • parse/lookup citation
  • text field for editing the unparsed text
  • moving citations up and down
  • new: allow users to move a citation anywhere in the editor
  • remove citation
  • add citation

Plugin Configuration

  • enable/disable L8X citation parsing
  • enable/disable automatic citation extraction
  • select/configure parsing services
  • select/configure lookup services

Implementation

  1. citation insertion
    • use existing text-area for input in submission step 2 (metadata)
    • "parse"-button triggers AJAX request that will insert the citation editor on the same page
    • open: non-blocking AJAX-request / progress-bar
  2. citation extraction
    • use full-page-request on file upload
    • if citations have been found then display a check-box (default: on) to enable citation extraction
    • citation editor will automatically appear in step two (metadata) with the extracted citations
  3. citation editor
    • port existing GUI to jQuery
    • "edit" triggers an AJAX request that inserts the citation field editor
    • "edit" closes other open field editor (if any)
    • "edit" for an open citation closes it
    • implement dirty-pattern to avoid losing user-data on editor close
    • "save details" and "save citation text" will become one single button ("save")
    • "save" triggers an AJAX request that persists citation text and citation fields to the database
    • "parse citation" and "lookup citation" will become one single button ("lookup")
    • "lookup" triggers an AJAX request for parsing and lookup that inserts lookup data into fields and provides the user with feedback for the parsing/lookup score
    • unparsed citation is implemented as text area
    • citation fields are implemented as input fields
    • "move up" and "move down" trigger AJAX requests that update the GUI accordingly (this is different from current implementation which triggers a full-page request that is not really usable)
    • "insert before" is a drop-down field that shows all citations by number, it has an entry "at the end..."
    • "remove citation" triggers an alert "do you really want to remove ...citation title...?" - if confirmed, an AJAX request will be triggered that persists the removal
    • "add citation" triggers an AJAX request that inserts a new citation into the GUI and opens the citation editor with empty fields
    • make sure that GUI conforms to PKP's standard design re-using existing CSS wherever possible
  4. configuration
    • check-box in setup - step4: enable/disable L8X citation parsing (if jQuery support is enabled then this will trigger the other options to appear)
    • check-box in setup - step4: enable/disable automatic citation extraction (available only if L8X parsing is enabled)
    • select/configure parsing/lookup services: use the existing GUI elements from L8X (no AJAX required, if jQuery support is enabled then dependent sub-options will only appear when the main service is enabled)

The Role of Plug-ins

When to do we need plug-ins?

  • non-standard installation requirements that need to be isolated
  • complex configuration or user-interface requirements that clutter the core interface for first-time users and should be kept out of the way
  • performance implications (when switching on a functionality causes a non-avoidable performance onus)
  • isolation of application-specific citation adapter code in one place to keep the core code clean -> improved code modularization and maintainability

Where to place citation plug-ins?

  • We'll have to create a new citation plugin category if we need additional hooks or have many plug-ins.
  • Otherwise we prefer to use existing categories.