PKP Bugzilla – Bug 7283
Grid checkboxes need some sort of information/explanation dialogue
Last modified: 2012-04-26 02:41:51 PDT
See, for example, the Reviewers grid on a Submission's Internal Review stage page. There's a checkbox there, but I have no idea what it does. I suspect that checking it may "complete" the review, but I'd rather not do that if I can't back out of it.
Scheduled against .8.1; feel free to bump if need be.
*** Bug 7288 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
*** Bug 7335 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
My suggestion is to add a text (a verb), just like all the other link actions. We can still have the icon, but with the proper text next to it. It will make much clearer what does that action and it's the easiest way to do this.
How do you feel about using the hoverTitle parameter that is currently available for link actions to have some text displayed when you mouse over the grid checkbox? We don't currently use it for anything. Technically, there is text in the grid cell now, but we use CSS to align it off of the page so you can't see it.
Another alternative is to create a div element with a small grid legend describing what each checkbox looks like and what it means. We can just include it on pages with grids.
I like the hover text. We tried to avoid the use of legends etc. because they clutter up the display, and that's one of the key things we were trying to avoid in the editorial interface. Editors are trainable (i.e. they'll work with the system for a long time) and once they've learned the iconography the legend will be dead weight.
In any case, there should be some indication both of what the current state is, and what clicking it will do.
Add hovering titles to grid checkbox status cells
Add grid status titles to common locale
Sorry for my late reply, but we were avoiding to use hover effects because of mobile devices.
We can use Jason's solution, that works pretty well on devices with mouse, but maybe we can try to build a place for help on grids. It could be used for a lot of things, including description that we don't want to insert on the main page but that we think that can help users to interact with the component.
I don't know if we call it help or info, but it could be a little interrogation icon with the "help" or "info" text next to it. It can be placed on top right (inside the blue component wrapper). When clicked, it should open a small div that reveals the help content.
For the icons case, I think that we can add an action inside the helper div that is shown with the text "show icons label", or something like that. If clicked, it shows in place what each icon means.
I don't think that this should be done right now, but it should be a concern for future releases because of the importance of mobile devices.
This may be quite simple to solve, if we add the 'help' icon you are describing. The text for the grid task is already in the cell, but the a.task CSS class applies a "text-indent: -1500px;" style to it. If you disable that CSS attribute, the text appears above the icon. Perhaps all that is necessary is a help icon that does this?
Well, it's quite simple but if we want to do it right it will take us some time, I think. Because we might want to use the help to do more than just showing labels that are already on grid. We might use it to show help content in a div, for example. So I think it's better to build something that's prepared to handle with that, or at least that's flexible enough to be extended. Because of this I think that we can use our current grid feature structure to add a help feature to our components.
Actually the grid features php implementation is missing, so we cannot avoid coupling features php code to our base components code, and that's a bad thing. I did that for ordering just because it was a must have for external testing and because the php features implementation would take an extra time that I didn't had.
But if we are going to use again the features structure, I think that we first need to finish it well. We might use it again for sorting and paging, so it's not time wasted. I just don't know if it's time to do it now.